lua-users home
lua-l archive

[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next] [Date Index] [Thread Index]


I just wanted a minor clarification.

Programming in Lua, fourth edition, pp.123-124, says
   “As an example, the next call is equivalent to loadfile:
    f = load(io.lines(filename, “*L”))”

If I understand correctly, this is no longer the case with Lua 5.4. Right?

In Lua 5.4, io.lines() now returns four values - iterator function, nil, nil, to-be-closed file handle - to conform to the new semantics of generic for loop. load(), however, hasn’t been updated, and still expects four arguments; chunk, chunkname, mode, env.

Hence, if I call load(io.lines(..)), **to-be-closed file handle** from io.lines() gets wrongly assigned to **env** argument of load().

I was a bit surprised with this behavior during my self-study. Wouldn’t it be nice if this is listed in the reference manual, section 8 Incompatibilities with the previous version?

Thank you for your time.

Below is what I did:

print(“hello world”)

Lua 5.3.5 Copyright (C) 1994-2018, PUC-Rio
> f = load(io.lines(“test.lua”, “L”))
> f()
hello world

Lua 5.4.0 Copyright (C) 1994-2020, PUC-Rio
> f = load(io.lines(“test.lua”, “L”))
> f()
(load):1: attempt to call a nil value (global ‘print’)


Sent from my iPad