• Subject: Re: Why do some math functions return -0
• From: caseyh@...
• Date: Sun, 19 Sep 2010 12:49:16 -0400

I haven't read all the replies; in some languages the modulus function is implemented differently for negative numbers. :)
```

Quoting Mike McGonagle <mjmogo@gmail.com>:

```
Well, here is the code that I am using, simplified to remove all the tables...
```
order = 3
elements = order * order
size = elements * elements

for i = 0, (size - 1) do
r = math.floor(i / elements)
c = math.floor(i % elements)
b = math.floor(math.floor(math.floor(r / order) * order) +
math.floor(c / order))
br = math.floor(r % order)
bc = math.floor(c % order)
```
print(string.format("i:%f r: %f c: %f b:%f br:%f bc:%f", i, r, c, b, br, bc))
```end

I would think that because all of the numbers that I am working with,
all the numbers would come out positive, but many of the resulting
'0's come out as -0. While I have tried to preliminary test to see if
"0 == -0", I am just wondering if by chance this is due to some
rounding error.

This is something that has bothered me about Lua for a while now, as I
don't really understand what '-0' really is or means. I mean,
logically, I can understand that there is probably some use for it,
but for the things that I am doing, I see absolutely no reason for it,
as I am trying to work with nothing but positive integers.

Thanks,

Mike

On Sun, Sep 19, 2010 at 11:53 AM, Drake Wilson <drake@begriffli.ch> wrote:
```
```Quoth Mike McGonagle <mjmogo@gmail.com>, on 2010-09-19 11:19:59 -0400:
```
```Hello all,

I have been doing some very simple things (mostly to get the integer
portion of a number) using math.floor, and it seems that sometimes the
function will return -0, when I am expecting a 0. Can someone please
explain why this happens? Is there a logical reason for this?
```
```
Why wouldn't they?  Negative and positive zero are two floating-point
representations with the same closest real number.

Can you give a specific example?

```
```Thanks,

Mike
```
```
---> Drake Wilson

```
```

```
```

```