lua-users home
lua-l archive

[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next] [Date Index] [Thread Index]

Environment: LuaJIT 2.0.0 beta 7, gcc 4.5.2, x86_64

While modifying the vstruct endianness detection code to play nice with 
luaJIT, I found that the vstruct test suite failed when run under luajit. 
Specifically, whichever floating-point test group ran second would fail, as 
would all of the randomly-generated bitmask unpacking tests.

After some investigation, I tracked the problem down to m.unpack[1], the 
bitmask-unpacking function (responsible for unpacking strings into lists of 
booleans). In the course of trying to debug this, I added a print()...and the 
problem went away.

I've now determined the following behaviour:
- with luajit -O3, it runs successfully but gets the wrong answers
- with luajit -O0, the same
- with luajit -joff, it runs normally and all tests pass
- adding, true) to the start of m.unpack also fixes it

It seems likely to me that this is a bug in luajit's compiler, since it runs 
fine in lua 5.1 and in luajit in interpreter mode. (Either that or I'm relying 
on some implementation-defined or undefined behaviour that happens to be the 
same in lua 5.1 and luajit -joff, but I can't find anything.)

I have no experience with luajit and no idea how to start debugging this, so 
any help would be appreciated. Unfortunately, I've been unable to create a 
minimal test case for this. If you want to reproduce it yourself, you'll need 
to do the following:

- download commit 1475192 from github[2]
- unpack it
- cd into the 'ToxicFrog-vstruct-1475192' directory
- run 'env LUA_PATH="" luajit vstruct/test.lua'
- replace "luajit" with "lua", "luajit -joff", and so forth, and observe the 

	Ben Kelly